Get a clearer picture of the costs, requirements and limitations behind each option

When you opened your practice, choosing a business structure may have been one decision among dozens. Since then, you may have hired providers, added a location or started talking with an associate about becoming an owner. Those changes can affect whether your original tax setup still fits. 

The best tax structure for a healthcare practice depends on how much profit remains after paying owners for their work, how ownership is divided and what comes next for the business. An S corporation may reduce employment taxes. A partnership may better accommodate different financial arrangements among owners. Schedule C offers simpler reporting for a single-owner practice. 

Consider two practices that each collect $8 million a year. In one, the owners see nearly every patient. In the other, several employed providers share the patient load. The revenue is the same, but the owners’ work and the profit remaining after paying them may be quite different. That is why annual revenue alone won’t tell you which structure makes sense. 

If your practice has grown but nobody has revisited its tax structure, the question is reasonable: “Does the way we’re taxed still make sense for the business we have now?” 

We’re an LLC. Do we still need to consider S corporation taxation? 

Being an LLC doesn’t tell you how your practice pays federal income taxes. An LLC is a legal structure, and it can be taxed in different ways. A single-owner LLC generally reports business income on its owner’s return, often using Schedule C. A multiple-owner LLC generally files as a partnership. An eligible LLC can elect S corporation taxation. 

For example, a dentist who operates through a single-owner LLC may have reported practice income on Schedule C for years. If S corporation taxation becomes a better fit, the practice may be able to keep its LLC legal structure and change how it is taxed. 

Your practice could therefore be both an LLC and taxed as an S corporation. Before comparing alternatives, confirm what return the practice files and which elections are already in place. 

The next step is to understand what would actually change. A tax election and a change to the legal entity are different steps. Depending on the proposal, you may need to review who is legally allowed to own the practice, insurance payer enrollment, contracts or financing. 

How do the main tax structures compare? 

Each option has advantages, but the trade-offs become clearer when you connect them to how the practice operates. 

Tax treatment  When it may fit  Owner employment-tax treatment  Main limitation 
Sole proprietor / Schedule C  One owner who values simpler income tax reporting  Net earnings generally face self-employment tax  Owner draws don’t reduce taxable profit or self-employment earnings 
Partnership  Multiple owners who need flexibility in their financial arrangements  General partners generally owe self-employment tax on business earnings; other partners require closer review  More complex reporting and rules governing allocations 
S corporation  Eligible practices with profit remaining after reasonable owner wages  Owner wages face payroll taxes; remaining business profit generally avoids self-employment tax  Reasonable compensation, ownership restrictions and less flexibility in allocating profits 

These are federal tax comparisons. State taxes and the costs of administering or changing a structure also belong in the calculation. 

How does self-employment tax affect practice owners? 

A practice owner may look at the money transferred to their personal account and assume that is the amount subject to tax. But leaving money in the practice doesn’t necessarily reduce the tax bill. For a sole proprietor, the calculation generally starts with practice earnings after business expenses, not the amount withdrawn. 

Self-employment tax covers Social Security and Medicare. Sole proprietors generally pay it on net earnings. General partners generally pay it on their share of business earnings and certain payments for their work. Other partners and LLC owners need a closer review of their situation. Receiving a K-1, the form reporting an owner’s share of business income, does not automatically mean those earnings avoid self-employment tax. 

This is one reason owners consider S corporation taxation. However, the claim that an S corporation “saves 15.3%” can overstate the benefit. 

Social Security tax has an annual earnings ceiling. Medicare tax does not, and higher earners may owe Additional Medicare Tax. For an owner whose earnings already exceed the Social Security ceiling, the potential savings may be smaller than that headline percentage suggests. 

The useful question is: “How much would our total tax bill change after reasonable salaries and additional costs?” 

When would an S corporation save a healthcare practice money? 

S corporation taxation may produce employment-tax savings when the practice earns profit beyond reasonable compensation for its working owners. 

Owners who perform services must receive reasonable wages before taking non-wage distributions. That compensation should reflect their clinical duties, management responsibilities, experience and other relevant factors. The IRS also considers whether receipts come from the owner’s services, other employees or capital and equipment. 

Consider two hypothetical practices with the same annual collections: 

Practice A  Practice B 
Owners provide nearly all clinical services.  Employed providers generate a substantial portion of collections. 
Little profit remains after reasonable owner compensation.  More profit remains after reasonable owner compensation. 
The potential employment-tax benefit may be limited.  The potential benefit may warrant a closer comparison. 

This example doesn’t establish an appropriate salary or promise savings. It shows why collections alone are a poor shortcut. 

S corporation status also doesn’t eliminate income tax on business profit. Owners generally report their share of earnings even when the practice retains cash for hiring, equipment or expansion. 

Would a partnership work better for a physician group? 

Picture a physician bringing an associate into ownership. The founding physician has more money invested in the practice, while the associate plans to buy in over several years. They need an arrangement that accounts for those differences and explains how they will share profits. 

Partnership taxation may fit a group whose owners need different economic arrangements. It can offer flexibility in dividing income and deductions, but the division must follow tax rules and reflect the owners’ actual financial agreement. Owners cannot simply assign deductions to whoever would save the most tax. 

An S corporation generally allocates taxable profit according to share ownership and has restrictions on eligible shareholders and classes of stock. 

Now suppose the two physicians eventually own equal shares, but one sees more patients. Equal ownership does not necessarily mean equal pay for their work. Their compensation can reflect different responsibilities, while ownership profits are handled separately. 

Different workloads don’t automatically rule out an S corporation, but the compensation arrangement and ownership distributions need to be handled correctly. Before choosing a structure, work through what happens when a physician joins, reduces hours or retires. 

Should a growing practice keep filing Schedule C? 

Schedule C can remain appropriate for a single-owner practice. There is no revenue threshold that, by itself, makes an S corporation the right answer. 

Still, consistent profit above reasonable compensation for the owner’s work is a reason to compare alternatives. So is a plan to bring another provider into ownership. 

One misconception deserves attention: taking a smaller owner’s draw does not reduce Schedule C profit. Self-employment tax generally follows net earnings, not the cash transferred to your personal account. 

Does an S corporation qualify us for the 20% business income deduction? 

The qualified business income deduction, or QBI deduction, is potentially available under all three tax treatments. Electing S corporation status does not automatically unlock it. 

Medical and dental practices generally fall within the specified service business category. Depending on an owner’s taxable income, the deduction may be reduced or unavailable. Practice revenue alone does not determine eligibility. 

S corporation wages and partnership guaranteed payments aren’t QBI. Retirement contributions and other deductions can also affect the calculation. Include those interactions in the comparison rather than assuming every owner receives a full 20% deduction. 

Can we reduce taxes without changing our structure? 

Yes. A review may show that the existing structure fits and that other planning deserves attention. 

Retirement plan design is one area to examine. Compare potential owner contributions with employee funding requirements, administrative costs and ongoing commitments. A staffed practice generally cannot use a solo 401(k) if it has eligible employees beyond the owner and spouse. 

Equipment purchases may also qualify for accelerated deductions, depending on the property and when it is placed in service. Start with what the practice needs and can afford. A deduction doesn’t make an unnecessary purchase profitable. 

What should we review before making a change? 

Ask for a side-by-side projection using your practice’s numbers. It should address: 

  • Reasonable compensation for each working owner. 
  • Federal and state taxes, including employment taxes. 
  • Retirement contributions and employee benefit costs. 
  • Administrative expenses and any costs triggered by the change. 
  • Cash available for owners and practice operations. 
  • Planned buy-ins, departures or a future sale. 

Use a normal operating year and a realistic growth scenario. If a second location or ownership change is coming, include it. 

The goal is a clear explanation of why the structure fits and what would cause that answer to change. 

Questions? 

Contact the Adams Brown healthcare team to compare your current tax structure with the alternatives. A review grounded in your practice’s numbers can help you decide whether a change is worth the cost and plan for it before your next stage of growth.