How do Families Balance Philanthropy with Long-term Wealth Preservation?
What to consider before making a large gift or long-term charitable commitment
“How much can we afford to give away? How much is enough to leave our children? We want to help them, but we don’t want to remove their motivation. What happens if we make a large gift and need that money later?”
These are questions we hear often from families. The desire to give is rarely the problem. The harder part is deciding how much to give, when to give it and which assets to use.
A family may want to support its community, establish a charitable legacy and involve the next generation. At the same time, that family may be preparing to sell a business, planning for estate taxes, helping adult children or protecting against future health care costs.
Step 1: Start With How Much is Truly Available for Charitable Giving
Net worth and available wealth are not the same thing.
Consider a couple whose business represents 80% of their net worth. They hope to sell within five years, but the timing and final value are uncertain. They also want to help their three children, maintain their current lifestyle and increase their charitable giving.
On paper, they may appear able to make a substantial gift. In practice, much of their wealth is concentrated in an asset they cannot easily sell. The business may also need working capital, equipment investments or additional cash during a difficult year.
Their first decision is not whether to open a donor-advised fund or establish a private foundation. It is determining how much wealth must remain available before anything is permanently committed to charity.
That amount should account for more than annual spending. It may need to cover future taxes, health care, support for family members, business obligations and a market downturn. It should also reflect how much the family wants to leave to children and grandchildren.
Once that financial floor is established, the family can better understand what is available for charitable giving. The answer may be a range rather than one fixed number. A family might be comfortable giving a certain amount now, with additional gifts tied to a future sale, strong business performance or another liquidity event.
Step 2: Do Not Build the Giving Plan Around the Best-Case Scenario
It is easy to make generous commitments when the business is growing and the market is up. The real test is whether those commitments still make sense when conditions change.
Some families use a fixed annual giving amount. Others base contributions on a percentage of their investment portfolio or make larger gifts following especially profitable years. A business-owning family may make modest annual gifts now and reserve its largest commitment for the year the company is sold.
A charitable reserve can also provide flexibility. The family sets aside money for future giving but does not promise it to a specific organization immediately. That leaves room to respond to an urgent community need or support a cause that becomes important later.
The goal is not to squeeze the largest possible gift out of the family’s balance sheet. It is to find a level of giving that can continue through good years and difficult ones.
Step 3: Timing Matters, Especially Before a Business Sale
Business owners often wait until a transaction is nearly complete before thinking seriously about charitable planning. By then, some opportunities may no longer be available.
A gift of appreciated stock or a closely held business interest may produce a different tax result than selling the asset and donating cash afterward. When properly structured, donating an appreciated asset can generally allow the donor to avoid capital gains tax on the donated appreciation while potentially qualifying for a charitable deduction, subject to tax rules and limitations.
Closely held business interests bring additional complications. The interest may need a qualified appraisal. Ownership agreements may limit transfers. The charity must be willing and able to accept the asset. If a sale is already effectively complete, the donor could still be treated as having received the income for tax purposes.
In plain terms, a business owner cannot complete the sale and then attempt to move backward in time.
Step 4: Choose the Structure After you Know What you Want it to Do
Families sometimes begin by asking, “Do we need a foundation?” A better question is, “What are we trying to accomplish?”
If the family wants a relatively simple way to contribute assets now and recommend grants over time, a donor-advised fund may be enough. It can be especially useful during a high-income year or following a liquidity event. Children and grandchildren can participate in recommending grants without the family operating a separate organization.
The contribution is irrevocable, however. Once assets go into the fund, they are dedicated to charity. The sponsoring organization has legal control, even though the family generally retains an advisory role over investments and grants.
A private foundation offers more control and can become a family institution of its own. Family members may serve on the board, set grantmaking priorities and build a formal process that continues across generations. That control comes with tax filings, annual distribution requirements, administrative costs and rules governing how the foundation operates.
For families that want to coordinate giving with income or wealth transfer, a charitable trust may be worth considering. A charitable remainder trust can provide income to designated beneficiaries before the remaining assets pass to charity. A charitable lead trust generally works in the opposite direction, supporting charity for a set period before the remaining assets transfer to family members or other beneficiaries.
The most complicated option is not automatically the best one. If a donor-advised fund meets the family’s needs, creating a foundation may add work without adding much value. The structure should serve the family’s purpose, not become the purpose.
Step 5: Talk About What the Children Will Receive and Why
The most difficult part of charitable planning may have little to do with tax deductions or investment returns. It may be deciding what future generations should inherit. One parent may want to divide most of the estate among the children. Another may believe the children already have enough. Adult children may have different financial needs, different relationships with the family business and very different opinions about which causes deserve support.
Avoiding those discussions does not eliminate the disagreement. It postpones it. A productive conversation begins with the purpose of the wealth. Is the goal to provide lifelong financial security? Help with education, housing or business opportunities? Preserve a company that employs family members and others in the community? Create a charitable legacy?
There is no required percentage that must go to heirs or charity. What matters is that the decision reflects a clear purpose rather than an unspoken assumption.
Philanthropy can also give younger family members experience with financial responsibility before they inherit significant assets. A family might give each child a modest grantmaking budget, ask them to research organizations and have them explain their recommendations.
The goal is not to make every family member care about the same causes. It is to give the next generation meaningful experience making decisions about money, responsibility and the family’s legacy.
Questions?
For many families, deciding how much is “enough” to preserve is harder than choosing where to give. But once that question is addressed honestly, generosity and financial security no longer have to feel like opposing goals.
These decisions work better when the people advising you are working from the same plan. Adams Brown’s Pinnacle Program brings tax, wealth and estate planning together for individuals and families with $1 million or more in investable assets. Your CPA and wealth consultant work together throughout the year to help you make informed decisions about what to give, what to preserve and how those choices fit into your family’s long-term plans. Contact Adams Brown to learn whether the Pinnacle Program is right for your family.
